Management challenge

Building a speak-up culture: management's role in psychological safety

By Auren Institute · The Compliance Management Journal · Published 25 August 2026

People speak up when they believe it is safe and worthwhile, and they stay silent when raising a concern feels risky or pointless, so a speak-up culture is built by the manager who changes that calculation every time someone takes the risk. Silence in a team is rarely because there is nothing wrong. It is because people have quietly concluded that the messenger pays and the message goes nowhere. Change what happens to the messenger, and you change what you get to hear.

Why psychological safety is a performance issue, not a soft one

Psychological safety, the shared belief that you can raise a concern, admit a mistake or ask a question without being punished or humiliated, is the strongest predictor of team performance, not a nicety on top of it. The term was defined by Amy Edmondson of Harvard in 1999, and it moved from academic idea to management priority when Google's Project Aristotle studied its own teams and found psychological safety to be the top factor separating high-performing teams from the rest (Google re:Work). The mechanism is simple: a team that hides problems cannot fix them, and a team that fears blame hides problems by default.

What silences a team

Teams go quiet for reasons a manager usually creates without noticing, and each has a direct counter.

  • The messenger gets punished. If the person who raises a problem is treated as the problem, everyone learns to stop raising them. This includes subtle punishment: visible irritation, a colder tone, being left off the next opportunity.
  • Nothing ever changes. If concerns disappear into a void, people conclude that speaking up is effort without result and stop spending it.
  • The manager never admits a mistake. A manager who is never wrong signals that being wrong is unsafe. Owning your own error out loud is the single fastest way to make it safe for others.
  • Concerns only travel through one blocked channel. If the only route runs through the person the concern is about, it does not get raised.

How managers actually build it

You build a speak-up culture through what you reward in the moment, not through a poster or a policy. The decisive moments are small and frequent.

The culture is set in the two seconds after someone raises a hard thing. If your first response is defensiveness, you have taught the whole team to stay quiet, whatever the policy says.

Thank people for the message even when it is unwelcome, and especially when it is about your own decision. Ask questions before you defend. Close the loop visibly, so that when someone raises a concern they later see what happened as a result, even if the answer was no. Admit your own mistakes in front of the team. And make sure there is more than one route for a concern to travel, so that a problem with a manager is not trapped behind that manager.

The compliance thread: speak-up culture is your best control

A genuine speak-up culture is the most valuable compliance control an organisation has, because most serious failures are known to someone inside long before they surface outside. This is also now a legal expectation. The EU Whistleblowing Directive (2019/1937) requires organisations, generally those with 50 or more employees, to provide safe internal reporting channels and to protect people who use them from retaliation. Malta transposed it through the Protection of the Whistleblower Act (Chapter 527), and the UK protects disclosures through the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998. But a reporting channel that people do not trust is a compliance decoration. The formal mechanism only works if it sits on top of a real culture where raising a concern is normal and safe, and that culture is built by managers, one response at a time.

What this means for the SME manager

For an SME manager, this is the rare area where the best management practice and the compliance requirement are identical, and both are almost free. You do not need a budget to build psychological safety. You need to notice the moment someone takes a risk to tell you something hard, and to make sure that risk pays off for them rather than costing them. Do that consistently and you get two things at once: a team that solves problems early because it surfaces them, and a compliance culture that would actually catch the serious thing before it becomes the serious thing.

Common questions

What is psychological safety at work?

Psychological safety is the shared belief that you can raise a concern, admit a mistake or ask a question without being punished or humiliated. The term was defined by Amy Edmondson of Harvard in 1999, and Google's Project Aristotle found it to be the top factor separating high-performing teams from the rest.

Why do employees stay silent about problems?

Employees stay silent when they conclude that the messenger pays and the message goes nowhere. Common causes are the person who raises a problem being treated as the problem, concerns that never lead to change, a manager who never admits a mistake, and a single reporting channel that runs through the person the concern is about.

How does a manager build a speak-up culture?

A manager builds a speak-up culture through their response in the moment: thanking people for unwelcome messages, asking questions before defending, closing the loop so people see what their concern led to, admitting their own mistakes openly, and making sure more than one route exists to raise a concern. Policies matter far less than these repeated responses.

Is a speak-up culture a legal requirement?

Safe reporting channels are a legal expectation for many organisations. The EU Whistleblowing Directive (2019/1937) requires organisations, generally those with 50 or more employees, to provide internal reporting channels and protect people from retaliation. Malta transposed it through the Protection of the Whistleblower Act (Chapter 527) and the UK protects disclosures under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998, but a channel people do not trust only works on top of a genuine speak-up culture.

More from the Compliance Management Journal

Auren Institute builds compliance training that changes what teams do, not just what they know, for HR and L&D leaders at SMEs in the UK and Malta.

See the compliance ladder
This article is general management and training guidance from Auren Institute. It is not legal advice. Where an employment law, data protection or whistleblowing obligation applies to your organisation, check the current position for your jurisdiction or take qualified advice before acting.